10 Reasons Not to Neuter Your Dog (an Unneeded Fix)

New dog owners are constantly advised to spay or neuter their dogs, for reasons ranging from overpopulation to behavioral adjustments. But are there any reasons not to neuter your dog?

As it turns out, the answer is yes.

Here are 10 reasons why it may actually be more responsible to not spay or neuter your dog. Take them into account before making any irreversible decisions!

10 Reasons Not to Spay or Neuter Your Dog

Trained different dogs playing in park at daytime

1. Spaying and Neutering Can Cause Weight Gain

Those sexual hormones that go hand-in-hand with canine fertility can have some unpleasant behavioral side effects. But since these hormones increase metabolism, they also play a role in weight control.

Spaying or neutering your dog results in lower hormone levels, which in turn leads to decreased metabolism and weight gain.

Many altered dogs gain a significant amount of weight if they’re not exercised more frequently and fed a lower-calorie diet. Overweight and obese dogs are at a higher risk of serious health conditions like diabetes, heart disease, and joint problems.

So consider your dog’s weight before neutering him. If he’s already on the chubby side, neutering him will only worsen the problem.

2. Neutering Increases a Dog’s Risk of Hip Dysplasia

Hip dysplasia is a relatively common condition in dogs, especially in larger breeds like Rottweilers, retrievers, and bulldogs. But regardless of breed, neutered dogs are more likely to develop hip dysplasia than intact dogs.

One study showed that dogs that were neutered before 12 months of age were twice as likely to develop hip dysplasia than dogs that were neutered later or not at all. And the early-neutered dogs developed the condition at a much earlier age than the other dogs.

If your dog is of a breed that’s prone to hip dysplasia, or if he’s a working or sporting dog, you may want to think twice about neutering him. Hip dysplasia is a debilitating condition that causes severe pain and limited mobility, so it’s not a risk to be taken lightly.

3. Neutered Dogs Are More Likely to Have Torn Ligaments

Ever torn or otherwise injured your ACL — the ligament that connects your thighbone to your shinbone? It’s extremely painful and greatly limits your ability to move until the injury heals.

Dogs have a similar ligament called the CCL, and when it tears, they experience similar symptoms: pain, lameness and difficulty moving. That’s no fun for you or your dog — and it’s much more likely to happen if your dog is neutered.

Studies have shown that regardless of size and breed, spayed and neutered dogs are significantly more likely to experience CCL tears than intact dogs. Active dogs are at an even greater risk of injury.

4. Neutering Can Shorten Your Dog’s Lifespan

You want your dog to live as long as possible, right? Well, neutering him could put him at a disadvantage in the longevity department.

Researchers studying Rottweilers found that female dogs that were spayed before four years of age had their life expectancies reduced by 30%. On the other hand, those that kept their ovaries for six or more years were nine times more likely to live for more than 13 years — a lifespan that’s considered exceptional for the breed.

5. Dogs May Become Incontinent After Neutering

Both male and female dogs are more likely to experience urinary incontinence after neutering. That means more accidents, more ruined floors and furniture, and more stress for both you and your dog.

Several studies have shown that spaying and neutering increases a dog’s risk of urinary incontinence by anywhere from 4% to 20%.

6. Neutering Can Make Aggression Problems Worse

Many people believe that neutering a dog makes him more docile and less aggressive, but in fact, the opposite may be true. One study (PDF link) showed that neutered male dogs were more likely to behave aggressively towards family members than intact dogs.

The same study also showed that neutered dogs were more likely to bark and growl excessively.

So think twice before neutering your dog to solve his aggression problems — you could end up making them worse!

7. Your Dog May Develop Hypothyroidism After Neutering

Two welsh corgi dogs

Neutering involves removing the gonads, which produce the sexual hormones that allow the dog to reproduce. But even if they’re removed, your dog still needs hormones, which means that other organs need to pick up the slack.

The thyroid is the main hormone-producing organ in your dog’s body. Without the gonads to help out, it needs to work much harder to supply your dog’s systems with the hormones they need.

This extra stress can result in hypothyroidism. It’s characterized by decreased levels of thyroxine, a hormone that regulates your dog’s metabolism.

Symptoms include weight gain, lethargy, hair loss, frequent ear infections, and sensitivity to the cold. Once developed, it’s a lifelong condition that requires daily medication to manage.

8. Neutering Increase Your Dog’s Risk of Developing Cancer

It’s true that neutering decreases your dog’s risk of developing certain cancers, particularly testicular, ovarian, and mammary cancers. But neutering seems to increase the risk of other cancers like lymphoma and osteosarcoma.

Spayed female dogs are five times more likely to develop heart tumors. And neutered Rottweilers have a 25% chance of developing bone cancer.

9. Neutered Dogs Are More Fearful than Intact Dogs

Early neutering is linked to increased fear and anxiety levels in dogs. This manifests largely in noise phobia: neutered dogs are more likely to be afraid of fireworks, thunder, yelling and other loud noises than intact dogs.

Fear can result in many unwanted or even dangerous behaviors, such as territorial aggression and leash reactivity. And while medications can help with anxiety, they can have side effects of their own, including dizziness, confusion and tiredness.

10. Dogs May Develop Pancreatitis After Neutering

Pancreatitis occurs when the pancreas, which produces digestive enzymes, becomes inflamed. This causes pain, vomiting, diarrhea, fever and, in severe cases, liver or intestinal damage.

Many dogs with pancreatitis require overnight veterinary care or intensive surgery during the course of their illness. And some cases of pancreatitis are chronic, so the symptoms will remain throughout the dog’s life.

Spayed and neutered dogs are around 3 times more likely (PDF link) to develop pancreatitis than intact dogs. This makes neutering particularly risky for breeds like miniature Schnauzers that are already predisposed to developing pancreatitis.

15 thoughts on “10 Reasons Not to Neuter Your Dog (an Unneeded Fix)”

  1. Neutering dogs without need is a horrible crime against someone who trusts you all his life. Vets say to neuter them because it is their business. Those who neuter their dogs are either very stupid or sadistic people. My did this to his dog who I loved so much. I think he did it under pressure of his liberal girlfriend who knows all truth about everything. I feel all weight of the crime they commited. The dog was not a small toy dog, he was a like a man… Unspeakable crime. I think the whole society is castrated mentally.

  2. I get to the same conclusion that neutering an animal which has asked for nothing is not a good service to him. Like cutting his tail, or his hears or anything I would avoid to be done to me, especially ‘in the name of good’ and of course in the blatant and for the name of bad.

    • What a stupid thing to say… are you not watching and caring for you dog… letting them lose to roam around the neighbourhood and get into a situation where they could make puppies? What an irresponsible owner you are. Love and look after your dog.

      • And who lets their dogs roam the neighborhood to make unwanted puppies or, worse yet, have someone poison and even kidnap them? You are the irresponsible owner.

      • Unfortunately, where I live, some owners let their dogs roam an entire neighborhood, if you talk to them they get angry for no reason, that makes me want to take care of their dogs and wait for that “wanted” sign, then bring it back (saying I found them lost somewhere) and teach their owner a lesson.

  3. I look at like. How spaying or neutering hurting and not helping the animal? Is it really more compassionate and human to keep the reproductive drive which is very strong in males at full force, while simultaneously prohibiting them from roaming and seeking out any relief for its natural cravings? I feel like neutering would be a blessing to my male dog who gets so frustrated sometimes it literally sounds like he’s crying and as a responsible owner I can’t let him go out and do what he wants to do and end up in the pound or responsible for making a bunch of ‘unwanted puppies’ I think it is even more human to get females spayed to prevent an unwanted pregnancy from occuring, which could happen anytime even when she is older and unable to safely have and care for a litter of puppies with the declined health and ailments of old age. It can even be life threatening.


Leave a Comment